I wanted to highlight this passage from the Pistols at Dawn extravaganza:
I've seen gamers try to create OtE characters where they pick a trait that is so broad it can apply to everything ("I have 4D in martial arts master/acrobat/strategist"), or take supposedly narrow traits and try to make them fit any situation ("I can use my 5D Football Champ trait to attack the thugs, right? Using my football training... oh, AND i can use my 5D football champ trait to beat the Chessmaster, because football has strategy that can also apply to chess").
To me, this is "Faking it". It creates situations where, by trying to encourage "roleplay" by giving positive bonuses to those who use their descriptors, it encourages people to try to stretch those descriptors to ridiculous limits.
Ditto with games that give bonuses for "descriptive stunting"; at that point every fucking action turns into a descriptive stunt ("I do a double backflip before sitting on the toilet to give me a +2D to taking a dump"; "I make an exaggerated courtsey when I meet Unimportant NPC x in case I have to get a bonus to my diplomacy check").
That's why Feng Shui has got it going on: there, you are ALLOWED to do any normal attack/action as a stunt, in a cool way and without penalty, as long as the end result not have a greater positive result than if you did it the normal way. For ex, instead of just saying "I run toward the guy and shoot him" you can say "I run three steps, jump onto the table sliding down off it shooting at the guy". Since the end result mechanically is the same ("Ok, roll to hit") there's no penalty for doing it acrobatically. Its "encouragement" in the sense of not fucking you over for giving your character a personal touch; rather than giving you a bonus for thinking up ways of dragging your personality into every little act.
- American Racing : Compete for stock-car dominance on 12 different tracks in this power-packed racing game. Free Online Car Games from ...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
The Star Wars Heromachine toy solved a problem for me. I needed a character sketch for one of my PCs for my upcoming Encounter Critical c...
-
Spongebob and Squidward held a jet ski match,you can choose the hero you like,and try your best to win the first prize.come on!
-
Me: How's it hanging? God: I am fine, thank you. Me: I hear your birthday is coming up. God: Who is saying my birthday is coming up?...
-
The prince of the fruit Kingdom fell in love with the princess of enemy country. they have no alternatives, the prince and the princes...
-
Honestly, now that I've seen the Tyranid codex in all its "glory", I think it's time for me to say it: I think Games Work...
-
Royal Spartans! Summer's been pretty dry for in terms of minis, but I have been playing a lot of computer games. Right now, I'm pla...
-
In D&D as I have known it for 20+ years most combat encounters go to a definite conclusion, mostly the death of one side in the conflict...
-
I'm probably going to get thrashed for saying this; but I think Dark Eldar are going to be a master-class army. I've read through t...
-
Looks like it's a write-off guys! You guys probably know that I like Phil Kelly's writing and design philosophies, but I have really...
No comments:
Post a Comment